Four Fights Campaign – Fair Pay, Job Security, Manageable Workloads, Equality
A BELOW INFLATION PAY RISE IS A PAY CUT… This year’s 1.5% pay offer is well below inflation – by any measure (RPI was 4.8% in August 2021). Since 2009 average pay in HE has dropped in real terms by 17.6% (RPI). AND THAT PAY CUT IS A CHOICE BY OUR EMPLOYERS… BUT NOT EVERYONE IS LOSING OUT! Staff costs are flat at Sheffield Hallam, but total income for the university is increasing and provisional accounts show a surplus (above budget) of £13 million for the year 2020-2021. The university continues to spend many millions on buildings, despite our students regularly telling us that ‘it is not the buildings that make this university’. The 10 members of the University Leadership Team shared £1.89 million in remuneration in 2020.
A FAILURE TO PROVIDE A FAIR DEAL TO CASUAL TEACHING STAFF… SHU relies on hundreds of Associate Lecturers on Zero Hour Contracts, on lower pro-rata pay and lacking many of the employment rights of permanent staff. Provisional year-end accounts show that spending on casual academic staff has increased by 71%, as a result of recruitment freezes and the non-renewal of contracts, even though the University made a healthy surplus. Surveys by Sheffield Hallam UCU branch show these workers overwhelmingly want to be on a more secure contract.
GAINS FROM YOUR LAST STRIKE ARE UNDER THREAT… In 2019-2020 Sheffield Hallam UCU took successful local action over high and increasing levels of workload, which are leading to long hours and unacceptable levels of stress. This was an important victory, but those gains risk being wiped out by additional duties imposed during the COVID pandemic, particularly now that temporary increases in workload allocation have been removed.
SLOW CHANGE ON EQUALITY PAY GAPS… While Sheffield Hallam has made some progress on the gender pay gap in the last 3 years, women, people with disabilities, and people of colour remain overrepresented in the lower pay brackets. Moreover, the pay gap between white males and women of colour is a shocking 31.7%.
Stand up for fair conditions and fair pay.
Strike FAQs – These FAQs have been complied by your UCU branch committee.
What action is our branch taking?
Sheffield Hallam UCU members have voted in favour of both strike action and action short of a strike (ASOS).
Why are we always going on strike?
Strike action has been forced by the employers in the sector who continually refuse to enter negotiations with UCU without a mandate for action. This is in spite of the fact that the demands which make up the Four Fights dispute are reasonable, fair, and affordable. Here at Sheffield Hallam, management continue to make decisions without consultation or consideration of staff, and we must be prepared to take action to prevent the further erosion of our terms and conditions.
Who is involved in the Four Fights Campaign?
The full list of ballot results from November, 21 is here.
The next ballot opens 6th March and closes Friday 8th April. Last day for posting Wednesday 6th April, ’22.
Last time strike action wasn’t effective. What’s different this time?
Last time local strike action was effective, by taking action members like yourself helped to win increases in workload allowances (including General Academic Duties, Marking and Assessment, and the reinstatement of certain roles against 462). It is true that the national action ended unsatisfactorily, but this was due to the Covid lockdown making further strike action impossible.
What actions are we expecting from this strike?
Further details about the aims of the Four Fights action can be found here:
Students have had a difficult couple of years. How can we expect their support?
This is a scare tactic to prevent you fighting for fair conditions. The National Union of Students have already said they support the UCU taking action. Remember that it is YOU who contributes to the student experience, not university management. Students demonstrate solidarity with their lecturers and support staff, not university management. You can help strengthen that solidarity by communicating the unfair conditions in higher education to your students and reminding them that the blame for strike action lies entirely with the employer.
How can we take strike action when the economy is in such a mess?
Sector leaders recognise the key role that universities have to play in the post-pandemic economic recovery. The employer cannot emphasise the central role of universities whilst simultaneously ignoring the harm caused to lecturers by their workplace policies. (In the 2020 Staff Pulse survey, academic staff gave an average score of 5.8 out of 10 in response to the question ‘I am maintaining a healthy work-life balance’.) The ‘Four Fights’ dispute is about challenging the unfair conditions and precarious labour the HE sector is built on.
The employer doesn’t have the money
Sheffield Hallam reported a £13million surplus at the end of the 2020/21 financial year. They do have the money.
I’m worried about the financial implications of striking. Is there support for me?
The rising cost of living is a real worry for us all. Since 2009 one below inflation pay rise after another have eroded staff pay by 17.6%. Enough is enough! The recent £250 ‘one-off’ payment offer to staff was framed around ‘rising energy costs and fuel bills’ by the VC. A recognition of the real term pay cuts at SHU and across the sector.
Remember, pay during a strike is now deducted on the basis of 1/365 per day. But there is also help from the union. The national UCU Fighting Fund exists to support those members for whom strike action might cause particular financial difficulties. Payments are typically available from the 4th day of strike action onwards and are currently set at £50 per day for those earning above £30k per year, and £75 per day for those on under £30k per year. In addition, Sheffield Hallam UCU maintains a small local strike fund (payments from which are prioritised for SHU’s many precariously employed academic staff)
Everyone is struggling at the moment. I’m embarrassed to strike when I have a relatively secure and well-paid role.
Remember that the fight to increase the pay offer will impact all staff at the University, including our support staff. We have academic colleagues who are still being held in insecure and exploitative hourly-paid roles (there is currently no conversion policy for ALs to apply for permanent roles at Sheffield Hallam). The use of ALs is increasing and there is evidence that managers are failing to uphold the few employment rights these staff have (https://lowpaysheffield.com/the-view-from-a-northern-heartland-[SCREEN].pdf – see page 53). It’s so important that we demonstrate the strength and solidarity of our union and reject exploitative and harmful employment conditions.
What does taking strike action mean?
Strike action means not doing any work for all of the days specified by the union (Wednesday 1st December, Tuesday 2nd December and Wednesday 3rd December). This includes, for instance, time before 9am and after 5pm and includes any activity which is part of your work such as teaching, administration, meetings, emails relating to work, marking, completing registers, research or conferences where you are directly or indirectly representing your employer. It also means not doing any preparation for work that you are due to do when you return to work after your strike. In a nutshell, if you are employed at one of the institution on strike don’t do any work at all on strike days!
If you are not yet a member, join UCU, so that you have protection of a trade union before you take part in industrial action.
You can join UCU at any point up to and including on the picktet line on the day of the action and lawfully participate in the strike action.
If you are not yet a member….Join online here!
I’ve never stood on a picket before. What should I expect?
Alongside the withdrawal of your labour, your local rep will contact members requesting that members volunteer to attend pickets, so look out for that. Having people on the picket is a really important way of communicating the messages of the industrial action to staff and students. This is essential to counteract the divisive messages from the employer which tend to characterise striking staff as a small group of agitators. You will see colleagues handing out leaflets, holding banners, and chatting with members of the university community. If you’re more comfortable just turning up and standing with colleagues, that’s great too. Remember, the longer the picket line, the shorter the strike! For guidance and information about picketing please see UCU picketing guidance
Do we have to leave work for students?
No, leaving work for students or providing them with work completion instructions will undermine the impact of the strike, this includes posting materials to Blackboard. If you’re being pressured to do this by a manager, contact your local rep.
Is there a suggested text I can copy for my out of office?
I am a member of UCU and will be on strike Monday 28th March, ’22 to Friday 1st April, ’22 inclusive. I will not be responding to e mails sent on these dates so if you require a response, please resend your e mail on a non-strike day.
If you are a student, the University should contact you in terms of how the industrial action may impact on you.
UCU is in dispute with employers over 4 issues explained here UCU_Four-Fights-Explainer: https://www.ucu.org.uk/media/10715/Our-four-fights/pdf/ucu_four-fights-explainer.pdf
I am a member of UCU and will be taking Action Short of Strike (ASOS) the potential scope of which is explained here: https://www.ucu.org.uk/ASOS-and-ARPS
There are also various graphics on the issues pertaining to the strike action here: https://www.ucu.org.uk/hedisputes You may wish to use these in email communications, or if you choose to talk about the strike with your students.
Do I have to tell my employer that I am taking strike action?
It is often the case that management will send out formal-sounding letters telling you to declare in advance whether you will be taking industrial action. This can have the effect of misleading and intimidating members. To be clear, you are under NO OBLIGATION to inform anyone in advance as to whether you will be taking part in strike action or action short of a strike. In order to fulfil legal requirements, employers have been provided with statistical information about UCU members taking industrial action, but not individual names. However, if your manager asks you after the strike whether you took action, you should answer truthfully.
What to say to non-members: the key message is don't cover - join UCU.
Non-members will get the pay increase and improved working conditions along with the many other benefits UCU have fought for over the years. The stronger the Branch, the stronger our hand.
If colleagues are “unable” to do this, the next best thing is to ask them to refuse to cover the work of striking colleagues. Grounds for refusal include:
- already being fully workplanned and being contracted to work a 37.5 hour week
- unless the work is comfortably within their usual area of work/expertise, refusal would be on the basis of professional integrity, maintaining a quality student experience and so on
- the NUS support the action
- they are on annual leave/RSA time
My question isn’t answered here.
There is a comprehensive list of FAQs published by the national committee.
If you have a query which is pertinent to the local context at Sheffield Hallam, please contact your local rep/officer.

